Backcountry Hunters & Anglers > Issues > Details

Welcome to BHA’s new website! This digital campfire is still being built—thanks for bearing with us as we get it burning bright.

Permitting Reform Moves Forward in Congress: What Hunters and Anglers Should Know

Backcountry Hunters & Anglers

Congress is considering a major overhaul of the federal permitting process. The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, or BAAJA, would change how federal agencies review and approve energy development, mining, transmission lines, and other infrastructure projects across the country. 

The legislation has gained significant bipartisan support in the Senate. On November 9, senators voted 73–25 to invoke cloture on the motion to proceed to H.R. 2347, the legislative vehicle for the permitting package. The following day, the Senate voted 62–21 to begin consideration of the bill. 

Lawmakers are now considering a substitute amendment and potential additional changes before final passage. The next procedural vote is expected on November 16. If approved by the Senate, the legislation would still need to pass the House before becoming law. 

Backcountry Hunters & Anglers is closely tracking the legislation and is engaging with congressional offices to understand how these proposed changes could affect the public lands, waters, fish, and wildlife that hunters and anglers depend on. 

 

Why Is Congress Considering Permitting Reform? 

Before a company can build a mine, construct a pipeline, or develop certain projects on federal public lands, it generally must secure permits and approvals from federal agencies. Depending on the project, that process can involve environmental reviews, consultation with wildlife agencies, water-quality protections, and opportunities for the public to weigh in. 

These requirements serve an important purpose. They help identify potential impacts to fish and wildlife, protect water quality, and ensure that decisions affecting public lands consider the interests of hunters, anglers, and other public land users. 

However, the federal permitting process can also be lengthy, expensive, and difficult to navigate. Delays can affect everything from major infrastructure development to conservation and habitat restoration projects. 

BAAJA aims to make this process faster and more predictable by setting clearer timelines, improving coordination among agencies, and providing greater certainty once projects receive federal approval. 

The bill also proposes changes to several longstanding environmental laws, including the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), Clean Water Act, and Endangered Species Act. 

 

What Could This Mean for Hunters and Anglers? 

BAAJA legislation includes hundreds of pages of proposed changes to federal permitting requirements. BHA is particularly concerned with two areas that could have significant implications for conservation: (1) Clean Water Act provisions and (2) the ability of federal agencies to revisit previously approved projects. 

 

Clean Water Act Changes 

Clean water is fundamental to healthy fisheries, productive wildlife habitat, and the hunting and fishing opportunities that depend on them. 

The Clean Water Act is one of the country's primary tools for protecting these resources. Among other provisions, Section 404 regulates the discharge of dredged or fill material into federally protected waters, while Section 404(c) gives the Environmental Protection Agency authority to prohibit or restrict certain discharges that would cause unacceptable harm to fisheries, wildlife, or other protected resources. 

Section 1204(a) of BAAJA would narrow the window in which EPA can exercise that authority. Under the proposal, EPA's ability to prohibit or restrict a disposal site under Section 404(c) would generally begin when a complete permit application is submitted and end when the permit is issued. 

Bill reference: Title II, §1204(a)(1)–(2), pp. 123–124. 

In plain terms, EPA would have less time to use one of its tools for protecting important waters and fisheries. For future applications covered by the provision, EPA would no longer have the same authority under Section 404(c) to intervene before a complete permit application is submitted or after a permit has been issued. The legislation would not eliminate EPA's broader responsibilities under the Clean Water Act. 

Why does this matter? Consider Alaska's Bristol Bay watershed. 

In 2023, EPA used its Section 404(c) authority to restrict certain discharges associated with the proposed Pebble Mine after determining that the project would cause unacceptable harm to the region's salmon fisheries. 

Bristol Bay supports one of the world's most productive wild salmon fisheries, along with local communities, commercial and recreational fishing, and a broader ecosystem that depends on healthy salmon runs. 

The legislation would not automatically undo EPA's existing Bristol Bay protections. However, it could limit EPA's ability to take similar protective action outside the newly established permitting window for future projects. 

For hunters and anglers, the concern is straightforward: Federal agencies need such tools to protect important fisheries and watersheds before irreversible damage occurs. 

BAAJA, as presented, would also make additional changes to Clean Water Act permitting, including state water-quality certification requirements and the duration of certain discharge permits. 

Bill references: §§1202–1203, pp. 115–123. 

 

Project Certainty: What Happens After a Permit Is Approved? 

Another major component of the legislation focuses on what happens after a project receives federal approval. 

Section 1401 would generally prevent federal agencies from revoking, suspending, withdrawing, or changing previously issued permits and authorizations, except under specified circumstances. 

Bill reference: Title IV, §1401(a)–(b)(1), pp. 158–160. 

The intent is to provide greater certainty for project developers. Once a project has secured its necessary federal approvals, developers would have greater assurance that those approvals could not be reversed or substantially changed by a future administration. 

However, public lands and natural resources are not static. Wildlife populations change, new scientific information becomes available, and previously approved activities can create environmental impacts that were not fully understood at the time permits were issued. 

BAAJA includes exceptions that would allow agencies to revisit approvals in certain situations, including when a permit holder violates applicable law or permit conditions, when an approval was obtained through fraud, when a court orders action, or when new information reveals certain urgent and substantial threats. 

Bill reference: §1401(b)(1)(A)–(E), pp. 159–160. 

Those exceptions are narrowly defined. In particular, the provision addressing newly discovered harm requires a specific, urgent, substantial, and proximate threat to life, property, national security, or defense. It does not expressly identify damage to fish, wildlife, or habitat as an independent reason for changing a permit. 

That does not mean agencies would lose all authority to enforce environmental laws or permit conditions. However, the legislation could make it more difficult to revisit previously issued approvals when new environmental concerns emerge. 

For example, if a mining project near Minnesota's Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness received federal approval, these provisions could limit a future administration's ability to revisit that approval in response to newly identified impacts on water quality or fisheries, depending on the circumstances and applicable legal exceptions. 

For BHA, this raises questions about whether federal land managers would retain sufficient flexibility to respond to changing conditions and protect public resources over the long term. 

Section 1402 would establish additional legal remedies for certain project applicants that demonstrate an intentional pattern of unequal treatment in federal permitting decisions. Successful applicants could recover economic damages and, under specified conditions, additional damages equal to 50% up to 100% of reasonably expected project construction costs. 

Bill reference: §1402, pp. 166–181. 

The provision is intended to discourage improper permitting delays and denials. At the same time, the potential financial consequences could create additional pressure on federal agencies reviewing controversial development proposals. 

The broader question is how to provide certainty for projects that have completed the permitting process while preserving the government's ability to protect public resources when conditions change or new information becomes available. 

 

What Comes Next? 

The Senate is continuing its consideration of the legislation, including potential amendments that could change its provisions before final passage. If approved, the package would move to the House for consideration. 

While permitting reform is not typically a focus of BHA's policy work, certain provisions within this legislation warrant careful consideration given their potential implications for public lands, waters, fish and wildlife habitat, and hunting and fishing access. BHA recognizes and understands the importance of reforming the permitting process to enhance efficiency and timeliness. However, efficiency and timeliness should not come at the expense of the integrity of our public lands, the wildlife that inhabit them, and hunting and fishing access.

As Congress continues its deliberations, BHA will closely monitor developments, evaluate any changes to the legislation, and remain engaged with lawmakers to ensure the interests of hunters and anglers are understood.

In the meantime, we encourage hunters, anglers, and all Americans who care about our shared natural resources to stay informed, follow the legislative process, and maintain an open dialogue with their elected representatives. An informed and engaged public is essential to ensuring that decisions affecting our public lands and waters reflect the interests of those who depend on them. 

Previous Article Doug Burgum, DOI Need to Heed the Will of the People
Print
154
Backcountry Hunters & Anglers

Backcountry Hunters & AnglersBackcountry Hunters & Anglers

The Voice For Our Wild Public Lands, Waters & Wildlife.

Other posts by Backcountry Hunters & Anglers
Contact author Full biography

Full biography

The Voice For Our Wild Public Lands, Waters & Wildlife.

x

Contact author

x